U.S. federal court jury finds Apple infringed three Qualcomm patents

Mobile chipmaker Qualcomm">Qualcomm has chalked up Apple-appeals-to-court-decision-china/">anotherQualcomm-Patent-dispute-forces-Apple-to-pull-iphone-7-and-8-from-its-stores-in-germany/">small legal victory against Apple in another Patent litigation suit.

A jury in a U.S. federal court in San Diego found Friday that Apple">Apple owes Qualcomm about $31M for infringing three Patents, per Apple-Qualcomm/Apple-infringed-three-Qualcomm-Patents-jury-finds-idUSKCN1QW2KB">Reuters.

Qualcomm has filed a number of Patent suits against the iPhone maker in the U.S., Europe and Asia in recent years. The suits are skirmishes in a bigger battle between the pair over licensing terms that Apple alleges are unfair and illegal.

As we Qualcomm-v-Apple-Patent-suit-trial-kicks-off-in-san-diego-ahead-of-next-months-big-one/">reported earlier the San Diego Patent suit relates to the power consumption and speed of boot-up times for iPhones sold between mid-2017 and late-2018.

Qualcomm had asked to be awarded up to $1.41 in unpaid Patent royalties damages per infringing iPhone sold during the period.

Reuters suggests the award could have wider significance if it ends up factoring into the looming billion dollar royalties suit between Apple and Qualcomm. By putting a dollar value on some of Qualcomm’s IP, the San Diego trial potentially bolsters the chipmaker’s contention that its licensing practices are fair.

We’ve reached out to Apple and Qualcomm for comment on the San Diego trial outcome.

At the time of writing it’s not clear whether Apple intends to appeal. Reuters reports the iPhone maker declined to comment on that point, after expressing general disappointment with the outcome.

In a statement provided to the news agency it said: “Qualcomm’s ongoing campaign of Patent infringement claims is nothing more than an attempt to distract from the larger issues they face with investigations into their business practices in U.S. federal court, and around the world.”

Apple filed its billion dollar royalties suit against Qualcomm Apple-Qualcomm/">two years ago.

It has reason to be bullish going into the trial now given a preliminary ruling Thursday — in which a U.S. federal court judge found Qualcomm owes Apple nearly $1BN in Patent royalty rebate payments (via Qualcomm-owes-Apple-nearly-1-billion-rebate-payment.html">CNBC). The trial itself kicks off next month.

The U.S. Federal Trade Commission also filed antitrust charges against Qualcomm in 2017 — accusing the chipmaker of operating a monopoly and forcing exclusivity from Apple while charging “excessive” licensing fees for standards-essential Patents.

That trial wrapped up in January and is pending a verdict from Judge Lucy Koh.

At the same time, Qualcomm has also been pursuing several international Patent suits against Apple — also with some success.

In December Apple-appeals-to-court-decision-china/">Apple filed an appeal in China to overturn a preliminary ruling that could have blocked iPhone sales in the market.

While in Germany it did pull older iPhone models from sale in its own stores in Qualcomm-Patent-dispute-forces-Apple-to-pull-iphone-7-and-8-from-its-stores-in-germany/">January. But by Apple-is-selling-the-iphone-7-and-iphone-8-in-germany-again/">February it was selling the two models again — albeit with Qualcomm chips, rather than Intel, inside.